Did you guys fill out "Disadvantaged Status" on AADSAS application?

It asks you yes or no if you think you are a disadvantaged student. I put no but I still filled out all the fields below.

doc3232

Full Member
10+ Year Member 15+ Year Member Joined Feb 15, 2008 Messages 3,809 Reaction score 10

Disadvantaged = Unemployed
You have to be REALLY poor. As in, the family made 20k a year with 5 kids.

DivaDent

Finally Finished
10+ Year Member Joined May 23, 2009 Messages 37 Reaction score 5

Come on people, really?! As if somehow disadvantaged = black. Not all black people are disadvantaged and not all disadvantaged people are black. I'm sure this will fall on deaf ears as anyone who would make (or find humor in) such an inference clearly has a certain set of "ideas."

Reactions: 1 user

doc3232

Full Member
10+ Year Member 15+ Year Member Joined Feb 15, 2008 Messages 3,809 Reaction score 10

Come on people, really?! As if somehow disadvantaged = black. Not all black people are disadvantaged and not all disadvantaged people are black. I'm sure this will fall on deaf ears as anyone who would make (or find humor in) such an inference clearly has a certain set of "ideas."


I agree. Those were some racist comments. Reactions: 2 users

Zubnaya Feya

Combinator
10+ Year Member Joined Nov 13, 2008 Messages 971 Reaction score 3

For those who put "no" for "Do you wish to be considered a disadvantaged applicant by any of your designated dental schools. " and still put info below that:

It says there in English: If yes, please answer the following questions.
Committees will doubt your RC score (or will reinforce their discontent of your already poor RC score). Just saying

vendredi

Membership Revoked
Removed 10+ Year Member Joined May 10, 2009 Messages 10 Reaction score 1 I agree. Those were some racist comments.


I wasn't born yesterday. I know a white guilt induced word when I see one. "disadvantaged" and "unique life experiences" smell badly of white guilt.

DivaDent

Finally Finished
10+ Year Member Joined May 23, 2009 Messages 37 Reaction score 5

I'm trying to understand why you would assume that in this case disadvantaged is referring to race. "Disadvantaged" and "unique life experiences" could be first-generation college student, physically disabled, low-income, foster child, etc. I think you're reading more into it. Disadvantages and unique life experiences don't only occur in the lives of black people. So should a white student from a low-income family not check the disadvantaged selection b/c the question is supposed to incite "white guilt" as you call it?

dentisttobeDMD

Full Member
10+ Year Member Joined May 27, 2009 Messages 116 Reaction score 0

so if you got significant amount of financial aid during college, unemployed, live in a house w/ a total of 6 individuals, would that be disadvantaged? also, is it to your advantage to say that you're disadvantaged?

Zubnaya Feya

Combinator
10+ Year Member Joined Nov 13, 2008 Messages 971 Reaction score 3

I think the individual schools will decide if you are disadvantaged or not no matter what you put in that section. Just my opinion.

bennijai

Full Member
10+ Year Member 5+ Year Member 15+ Year Member Joined May 23, 2006 Messages 644 Reaction score 1

I qualified for the Pell grant but I don't feel that it makes me at a worst situation than others. I'm leaving the section blank even with low income.

wizardsradio

Full Member
10+ Year Member Joined Jan 12, 2009 Messages 31 Reaction score 0

I'm not sure if I should fill out this section or not. I get pell grants and a bunch of other grants, but it is because I got married and my wife had a child our freshman year. Im the first one in my family to go to college, but I would feel kind of silly filling out most of these sections because my parents made a combined $100,000+ most my life and I group up in a nice area. So I basically have only been "disadvantaged" for the past 2 years of my life. I actually feel better off than most college students because my wife and I get enough combined grants to pay for all of our school plus living expenses with only taking out like $4,000 in subsidized loans each year. What do you guys think?

tinman831

¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Staff member Administrator Volunteer Staff Lifetime Donor Verified Member Dentist Verified Expert 15+ Year Member Gold Donor Joined Dec 11, 2004 Messages 11,412 Reaction score 143

Ignore the comments on race. If you believe you are disadvantaged as far as finances are concerned, put it down. You have a chance to explain yourself when you apply for school loans or government loans. They have the final say as to who is considered disadvantaged or not.

miedvied

Full Member
10+ Year Member Joined Apr 23, 2009 Messages 146 Reaction score 1

Is disadvantaged only a matter of finances? Does anyone know of someone that marked off disadvantaged due to a physical disability?

I'm a disabled student, but I'm conflicted on whether or not I want to disclose that on the app. I don't really need them wondering whether I'll be able to survive school because I have an illness.

doc3232

Full Member
10+ Year Member 15+ Year Member Joined Feb 15, 2008 Messages 3,809 Reaction score 10

Is disadvantaged only a matter of finances? Does anyone know of someone that marked off disadvantaged due to a physical disability?

I'm a disabled student, but I'm conflicted on whether or not I want to disclose that on the app. I don't really need them wondering whether I'll be able to survive school because I have an illness.

It really depends on the disability. If it won't affect your ability to be a great dentist then mention it.


I think this is a decent definition of disadvantaged: Having trouble putting food on the table.
If you are getting lots of financial aid then I wouldn't claim to be disadvantaged.

Dental Mom

Full Member
10+ Year Member 15+ Year Member Joined May 19, 2005 Messages 457 Reaction score 4

Is disadvantaged only a matter of finances? Does anyone know of someone that marked off disadvantaged due to a physical disability?

I'm a disabled student, but I'm conflicted on whether or not I want to disclose that on the app. I don't really need them wondering whether I'll be able to survive school because I have an illness.


Do you have learning disabilities? You should always point out your strengths in the application and put more weight on what you can do. And if you have LD you should not put that on the application. Send me a private message if you want.

bennijai

Full Member
10+ Year Member 5+ Year Member 15+ Year Member Joined May 23, 2006 Messages 644 Reaction score 1

I'm not sure if I should fill out this section or not. I get pell grants and a bunch of other grants, but it is because I got married and my wife had a child our freshman year. Im the first one in my family to go to college, but I would feel kind of silly filling out most of these sections because my parents made a combined $100,000+ most my life and I group up in a nice area. So I basically have only been "disadvantaged" for the past 2 years of my life. I actually feel better off than most college students because my wife and I get enough combined grants to pay for all of our school plus living expenses with only taking out like $4,000 in subsidized loans each year. What do you guys think?


Unlike you my parents combined income was around 30k every year after taxes. Yes we are pretty damn broke. haha.